Monday, 25 March 2019

Criticizing the Ban on Public Gatherings - December7 1918


By the end of the first week of December 1918, the Hamilton Board of Health and the Hamilton Medical Association were under withering criticism from the Spectator because of the second round of orders banning public gatherings. For three consecutive days, on the front page, the Spectator published a satirical take on the influenza epidemic and how the matter was being handled. The form chosen was a mock question and answer format with made-up questions from made up readers:

 “ Knutty Points

“Ask Us – We Don’t Know”

If it is dangerous for clerks to wait on customers after 4 o’clock in the afternoon, how is the overworked Proprietor immune?

                                                                       ANXIOUS

Our Hoyle is silent on this point. Ask the doctors. – Ed.

_____________________________________________

Is it worse for one man to serve fifty customers in his store after 4 o’clock than to have the assistance of his clerks and disperse the crowd more quickly.

                                                                 BEWILDERED

Common sense seems to approve of retaining the clerks, but the doctors have decreed otherwise. – Ed.

__________________________________________

Is the ‘flu’ germ more active after 4 p.m. than previous to that hour?

                                                                        I WONDER

Once again, we are stumped. Will some doctor please explain? – Ed.

_________________________________________________

Why, in the name of all that is sane and proper, if the ‘flu’ is more deadly than small pox, haven’t the cases been isolated and placed under quarantine?

                                                                       IVA KAUFF

If uva cough, Iva, your doctor should be able to answer that question. – Ed.

_______________________________________________

Please tell me why members of the board of trade and other business men can spare time to go to the city hall and beg the ‘people’s representatives’ to do things, but cannot do their duty by serving as city representatives?
                                                                      TAXPAYER

Will business men please answer? –Ed.

____________________________________________________

 Is it safer to stand on a street corner for an hour, waiting for a car, than to ride on a crowded one?

A. HOOFER

The doctors say it is. So there. – Ed.1

1 Hamilton Spectator.    December 05, 1918.



Knutty Points : “Ask Us – We Don’t Know”

“Please tell me if warning Brantford people to stay away from Hamilton comes under the head of good advertising for Hamilton’s publicity department?                                                                                     PERTURBED

Common Sense answers this one. – Ed.



“If I am late for work because I have to wait nearly an hour for a car, to whom should I refer my annoyed employer?                                                    WORKER

“To the doctors. – Ed.



“If influenza starts with a common cold, are children safer playing in the snow than in school, where they are under the watchful eye of teachers and school nurses?                                                                   MOTHER

“The medical men evidently think so. – Ed.



“If I suffer from a common cold, why should a notice be sent to the board of health that I have influenza? Does it make a difference to the size of my medical bill?                                                        U.  KALIPTUS

“We pass these along to the doctors. – Ed.



“Will the committee of medical men stay on the job after the influenza is curbed and assist in healing ruptured business organizations, sickly trade and bruised feelings?                                           P.B. PUBLICO

“That remains to be seen. – Ed.



“Why should it be necessary to close churches in Hamilton, when Toronto, where the epidemic has been just as serious, they have been left open?                                                                                              LIKETOKNOW

“Perhaps the Toronto doctors go to church. – Ed.



“If the library is closed because of the danger of infection from people and germs, what is to prevent the latter pesky little creatures nestling between the leaves of books for years to come?              A. BOOKWORM

“Please inquire of the janitor.”2

2  Hamilton Spectator.    December 06, 1918.







 “ Knutty Points

“Ask Us – We Don’t Know”

Please tell me any sound reason why the stores should not be permitted to remain open on Saturday evenings, the majority of the factories closing at noon and easing congestion on street cars?

                                                            MAG NANIMOUS

This seems to be up to the doctors to answer. – Ed.

_____________________________________________

Why not dispense with the board of health altogether, and let the medical association do the work?                                                                        BULL SHEVIKI

Give ‘em time, Bull; give ‘em time. – Ed.

__________________________________________

Would much coal be saved if staff of the public library was given a vacation, the building being closed to the public? 
                                                                                                                                                             BOOK WORM

Why worry about coal, when the books have to be dusted – Ed.

_________________________________________________

Why not prohibit fat people from riding on street cars, thus making it possible for more passengers to be carried?                                                                                                                                                              SKINNY



This is apparently a slight  oversight on the part of the medical men. But they can’t think of everything, can they?. – Ed.

_______________________________________________

How do you account for the churches being closed tight tomorrow, while the hotel barrooms will be crowded ? 

                                                                                                                                                     REFORMED BOOZER

Perhaps only ‘good’ beer will be ‘on’ –Ed.

____________________________________________________

 I am a descendant of Scottish covenanters. Should I not resist this church closing edict for conscience sake ?

B. HOOFER

You are living in the 20th century now. You are too archaic . – Ed.3

          3Hamilton Spectator December 7, 1918


No comments:

Post a Comment